• Skip to main content
Four Columns Marketing
X
Four Columns Marketing
  • About
  • Services
  • Specializations
  • Results
  • Insights
  • Contact
844.368.7265
[email protected]

Consent Is Changing How We Measure Website Performance

11/17/26

|

Matt Silva, SVP Technology, Four Columns Marketing

Enhanced privacy laws have impacted website tracking capabilities. Here’s how to stay compliant and track marketing results with less data.

For a long time in digital marketing, marketers have relied on being able to track what users are doing on a website. We use tools like Google Analytics to find out how many people came to the website, where they came from, what they did when they got there, and ultimately whether or not they converted. Privacy laws and website consent are changing that.

Now, businesses need to allow users to decide whether they want to be tracked, and how — requiring a slew of technical changes to your site. At Four Columns, one of the tools we’re using to manage this is Cookiebot by Usercentrics.

What is Cookiebot?

Cookiebot is a consent management platform that gives website visitors the ability to make that choice and then helps control which tracking technologies can run based on their consent. 

One of the first things businesses need to understand is that once something like Cookiebot is added to your website, the number of trackable users and events you see in Google Analytics can go down. That does not necessarily mean your traffic went down. It means the amount of your traffic that you can see went down. That distinction is going to become more and more important as we move forward in the new age of consent.

Why Should I Add Cookiebot?

A fair question would be: “If adding Cookiebot means I can potentially see less data, why would I want to do that?”

The simple answer is because businesses can’t ignore the legal environment that exists today. There are laws and legislation that question how users are tracked online. Some of these laws were written before the technology we use today even existed, but new interpretations are rolling out every day that apply them to online data privacy. This isn't a phenomenon isolated to one company or one industry. Everyone in digital marketing is trying to figure out what the new environment looks like. 

One of the challenges is that consent requirements aren't the same everywhere. This is another reason why consent management has become more complicated than simply putting a cookie banner on a website. Depending on where a visitor is located and the privacy requirements in that location, more or fewer restrictions may apply. Not giving users the proper choices about tracking can put a business at risk for a lawsuit. Even though implementing consent can make marketing measurement more difficult, ignoring the issue isn't a safe choice either. 

If you’re not sure where to start, reach out to us. We’ve set up Cookiebot for many of our clients and would be happy to help.

How to Work With Less Data

Historically, conversion tracking has been built around our ability to track key events through Google Analytics. We could see someone come to a website, see what they did, and hopefully connect that activity to a conversion. With privacy laws and users having more control over tracking, that information is becoming harder to see clearly. It doesn't mean tracking is entirely impossible; it just means marketers have to adapt.

For the visitors who opt in, a lot of what we've always done stays the same. We have access to the data and can use it to understand what those users are doing. The new challenge is figuring out what the data we can see might tell us about the users we can't see.

Here’s an easy way to think about it:

Imagine you were suddenly dropped into a country where everyone spoke a language you didn't know. You might not understand exactly what someone is saying to you, but that doesn't mean you have no idea what’s going on. You can look at their expressions, their gestures, and see what's happening around you. You can use your past experiences to start picking up on signals and interpreting what that person is trying to tell you.

Marketers are going to have to start doing the same thing with their data. We can look at the users who have consented to tracking and spot trends that can be attributed to a larger audience. Then, we can combine that with the other signals we have to gain a better understanding of what might be happening with the users we can't directly track.

What You Should Expect From Your Marketing Agency

In my opinion, a lot of the digital marketing industry got hit with this change without really having a plan for how to proceed. You should be partnering with an agency that knows how to interpret the data without the full picture. It’s no longer enough to just hand a client a report showing users, sessions, and conversions. Your agency should be figuring out which signals matter and what those signals are telling you about the customer.

If the trackable users are showing a certain trend, what can we learn from that? Are we seeing that same trend in leads? Phone calls? Sales? Revenue? Are there other signals that support what we're seeing? This is where experience is necessary.

Technology is also more important now than ever. Your agency should be using the right technology to automate reporting and bring different signals together. Marketing trends can change quickly. If it takes weeks to figure out what happened, you're already behind. An agency that can consolidate data, recognize what is changing, and move quickly to do something about it is far more valuable than a million dashboards.

How Less Data Can Lead to Better Marketing

Having less trackable data is not necessarily bad for business. It just means that businesses and their marketing agencies need to have a better understanding of their customers. 

A few questions you should be asking:

  • Who are you trying to reach? 
  • What does that customer actually want? 
  • What problem are they trying to solve? 
  • Why is your company the answer to that problem?

Those questions have always been important, but they're going to become even more important when we can't depend on tracking every action a user takes.

The business understands its customers. Their marketing agency should be able to take that knowledge, combine it with the data and signals they can see, and determine a strategy to apply across all of the company's marketing channels.

The goal hasn't really changed. We're still trying to understand the customer, get the right message in front of them and show them why a product or service can solve their problem. We're just going to have to get better at doing that without being able to see every step they take along the way.

At the end of the day, if your product or service is what the customer wants and your marketing is getting that solution in front of the right people, your bottom line will eventually tell you whether those efforts are working. Google Analytics is an important tool, but it isn't your entire business.

If you have any questions about adding Cookiebot to your website, or how consent is affecting what you see in your reporting, reach out to Four Columns. We can help you manage consent and make more out of the data you can track.

Matt Silva is the Senior Vice President of Technology at Four Columns Marketing, where he has led website design and development since 2014. He received his Associate of Science in Web/Multimedia Management from Texas State Technical College in Waco, and has served as Chairman of the Board of Advisors for TSTC’s Web Design & Development program since 2012. He has over 15 years of experience in web development, technology leadership, and business planning.

  • About
  • Services
  • Insights
  • Contact

Waco

100 6th Street, Suite 100
Waco, TX 76701

Dallas

15305 Dallas Pkwy 12th Floor
Addison, TX 75001

Houston

1201 Fannin St, Suite 262
Houston, TX 77002

New York City

41 Madison Ave 31st Floor,
New York, NY 10010

Denver

2301 Blake St Suite 100,
Denver, CO 80205
Hubspot Certifaction Badge
google partner badge
Social Media Badge
Best Web Developers in Waco Texas Badge

Copyright ©  2026 | Privacy Policy